For me, it is rare when a new musical is completely captivating and immediately joins my list of top favorite musicals. However, Becoming Nancy is that rare musical.
The Alliance Theatre’s new musical helmed by two-time Tony award winning director Jerry Mitchell, portrays the story of David Starr, a lovable high school theatre kid. David is forced to reinvent himself after receiving the part of Nancy in his school’s production of Oliver. Even though David is up to the challenge, his parents and peers are not supportive of the casting decision. Thus, David is compelled to find his own confidence to take the stage and be a voice for others who are not always appreciated by 1979 London society.
With many Broadway veterans, the show brings depth to the struggles and joys of family life, high school, and first love. Zachary Sayle leads the show as the likable David Starr. He completely engages the audience from the moment he steps onstage until curtain call, making him the perfect person to lead the audience through David’s journey. The many other actors that join Mr. Sayle such as Stephen Ashfield, Jessica Vosk, Jasmine Rogers and Jake Boyd as David’s friends and family give powerful performances in their respective roles.
As I walked into the recently renovated Coca-Cola Stage, the bright set immediately caught my attention. The show’s set designer, David Rockwell, does an impressive job of creating a multi-use set that is bold but not overbearing. To compliment the set, lighting designer, Philip S. Rosenberg is able to enhance the mood of each scene. In the large opening numbers, the lighting is brilliantly colorful and exciting, but the lights quickly dim to support some of the darker moments of the show.
Besides the technical aspects of the show, Elliot Davis’s book is very witty and relatable, especially for those who are in high school, and George Stiles and Anthony Drewe’s heartwarming music and lyrics give a subtle nod to the height of 70’s music while supporting crucial moments in the show. With its intense choreography and entrancing performances, Becoming Nancy is a must see!
-Emily, 12th grade